What are the reviews for That Time I Got Reincarnated as a Slime?

When you hear the title That Time I Got Reincarnated as a Slime for the first time, you probably pause for a second. A slime? Really? In a world full of overpowered swordsmen, chosen heroes, and demon lords, who would ever want to be a slime? But that’s exactly what makes this series so special. And if you’ve been curious about what people actually think of it, the reviews for That Time I Got Reincarnated as a Slime are overwhelmingly positive and for good reason.

Fans who picked up the light novel, manga, or the anime adaptation usually come in with curiosity and maybe even a bit of skepticism. But within a few chapters or episodes, they’re hooked. The story of Satoru Mikami, an ordinary 37-year-old man who gets reincarnated into a fantasy world as, of all things, a slime, sounds like a parody at first. Instead, it quickly evolves into one of the most engaging isekai tales out there.

So what do people actually say in their reviews? A lot of readers and viewers point out how refreshing the series feels compared to other isekai. Yes, it has the usual tropes: reincarnation, RPG-style skills, monsters, and a growing kingdom, but the execution is what wins everyone over. Rimuru Tempest, the slime protagonist, is often described in reviews as one of the most likable and unique leads in the genre. He’s not cocky, not arrogant, and not obsessed with power for the sake of power. Instead, most reviews emphasize how Rimuru’s personality is kind, fair, but still strategic and occasionally ruthless, making him a protagonist worth following.

When you look at reviews of the manga, readers talk about how clean and fun the art is. The worldbuilding shines, and people love how even supporting characters feel fleshed out. The pace can be slower at times, but many reviews say that’s part of the charm; it’s not a story rushing from battle to battle, but one that takes the time to explore alliances, friendships, and the building of an entire nation. Fans especially mention how satisfying it is to see Rimuru go from being a tiny, powerless blob to becoming the leader of the Jura Tempest Federation, earning the loyalty of monsters and even humans.

On the anime side, reviews often praise the adaptation for staying faithful to the source material. The animation by 8bit is solid, with fight scenes that pop and character designs that look even better in motion. Many reviews mention how the first season surprised them with its balance of action and lighthearted comedy, while the second season dialed up the stakes with political intrigue and heartbreaking twists. It’s the kind of series that knows when to be fun and when to hit you with emotional punches.

Of course, not all reviews are 100% glowing. Some people do mention that the pacing, especially in the middle arcs, can feel slow. Rimuru’s kindness, which is a strength for many fans, can also feel like a weakness to some reviewers who want a darker, more ruthless protagonist. But even then, the criticisms usually come with a note like, “but I still love it,” or “it’s a minor issue compared to the overall quality.” In other words, even the less enthusiastic reviews still admit the series has something special.

What’s interesting is how broad the appeal is. If you read through different communities online, you’ll see reviews from longtime isekai fans saying it’s one of their favorites, and reviews from people who usually avoid isekai saying this one changed their mind. That’s rare. The fact that Slime manages to win over both hardcore fans and skeptics says a lot about how well it’s put together.

A lot of the positive reviews also highlight the supporting cast. Characters like Shion, Shuna, Benimaru, Diablo, and Milim consistently get shoutouts. Fans love how Rimuru’s allies aren’t just background decoration but active, fun, and layered personalities. Many reviewers point out that you don’t just care about Rimuru, you care about the entire Tempest family. That sense of community is something that shows up again and again in people’s comments.

The worldbuilding gets plenty of love, too. Reviews often compare it favorably to other fantasy isekai, noting how the politics, nations, and even the economy feel surprisingly well thought out. Rimuru isn’t just battling monsters, he’s signing treaties, managing resources, and trying to build peace in a world filled with conflict. That “kingdom-building” aspect gets a ton of praise, especially from readers who want more than just endless battles.

Another thing that keeps coming up in reviews is how the story manages tone. On the surface, it looks like a lighthearted adventure with a squishy slime mascot. But reviewers often talk about how the series isn’t afraid to go dark when it needs to. Death, betrayal, war—these things hit hard when they happen, because they’re balanced by moments of levity and warmth. That balance is one of the biggest reasons people say the series stands out.

If you’re curious to see what people are saying for yourself, you can always check out fan discussions and updates at places like tenseishitaraslimedattaken.com. It’s fun to scroll through different takes and see how readers from all over the world react to Rimuru’s journey.

So, to sum it up in a casual way: the reviews for That Time I Got Reincarnated as a Slime are really, really good. People love it for its fresh take on the isekai formula, its lovable main character, its strong supporting cast, and its surprisingly deep worldbuilding. Sure, some folks think the pacing could be tighter or that Rimuru is “too nice,” but even those reviews tend to recommend it anyway.

And if you ask me personally? I’d say the reviews aren’t exaggerating. It’s one of those series you might come into with a raised eyebrow, thinking “how good can a slime story really be?” and then before you know it, you’ve read a hundred chapters, watched two anime seasons, and you’re looking forward to the movie. That’s the mark of a story that connects with people, and the reviews are just reflecting that connection.

So if you were wondering what the reviews are like, the answer is simple: overwhelmingly positive, with just enough criticism to keep things balanced. But the general vibe is clear: Rimuru Tempest has slimed his way into a lot of hearts, and most fans are more than happy about it.